THIS ARTICLE WAS WRITTEN BY RENE LOPEZ. IT IS A VERY GOOD EXPOSITION OF WHAT FREE GRACE IS ALL ABOUT.
Basics of Free Grace Theology
Introduction
For most of my early life I was raised in a type of Roman Catholicism with an emphasis on Witchcraft, known as Santeria. While being in a family that practiced Santeria I saw many miraculous things. Thus, early in my life I was convinced of the existence of the supernatural. Hence the evolutionary teaching usually taught in schools was never convincing to me.
Until my late teens and early twenties I did not consider the protestant faith. One day a middle-aged man from the Seventh Day Adventist (SDA) Church introduced me to Jesus Christ in a special way. Though I was still using drugs I began attending church. Not long after that I knew Jesus was the answer to many of life’s questions I had, since I was always a thinker and a philosopher that never missed asking the “why” questions of life.
Although I got baptized in the SDA church I was never certain of my eternal destiny since the SDA is Armenian in its theology. Only until I left the church, got in trouble with the law, and landed in prison, was I confronted with God’s free offer of eternal life. While in prison working as a Chaplin’s aid I remember debating someone that unless one continuous to behave properly one forfeits salvation. To no avail—at that time at least—I remember how this older man continued to emphasize that salvation comes by faith alone and no amount of works afterwards can contribute either to gain it or lose it.
After getting out of prison I began attending Miami Christian College, which was soon bought by Trinity International University (the undergraduate campus of TEDS). Thus I began pursuing my purpose for living: to preach and teach God’s Word which was the only thing that gave meaning to life. Interestingly, I never forgot my debate about salvation with the gentleman; though I don’t have an exact time and date I remember while attending Trinity that I was certain I had eternal life simply because Jesus promised it, as that man had once said. I remember thinking: “How wrong I was.”
While in Trinity I remember feeling a passion for studying the issue of salvation because of the confusion that existed. I started studying the debate of Lordship Salvation between John F. MacArthur and Zane C. Hodges. Reading MacArthur left me uneasy, but after reading Hodges, having taken some Greek and theology courses it all made sense to me.
I called Zane from Miami and told him I was planning to attend Dallas Theological Seminary (DTS) and wanted to meet him and perhaps work for him since I had read in back of his book, Absolutely Free, he was the pastor at Victor Street Bible Chapel. So that is what I did. As soon as I began at DTS, Zane began to disciple me and I began preaching and teaching at Victor Street Bible Chapel.
Besides working at Victor Street I also worked in New Life Clinics formerly owned by Minirth and Meier, which today is owned by Steven Arterburn and Paul Meier.
During that time the gospel became clearer to me. I felt the need to pastor and left to do so in Miami, Florida. There I started a church and began teaching in my old alma mater Trinity as an adjunct professor. As a result I felt in love with teaching the Word in a deeper academic level. Since I knew the impact that many professors had on me, I wanted to have that same impact for Jesus on others. Hence I returned to DTS and enrolled in the doctorate program.
While I began growing more in my knowledge of Scripture, my passion for the clarity of the gospel never changed. Unfortunately what has not changed is the confusion that still exists on the gospel today, even in our own circle of grace.
I would like to credit and thank Dr. Charlie Bing for coming up with the idea on training people on the fundamentals entailed in Free Grace Theology. I would also like to thank Dr. Robert Wilkin for providing a good part of the content below, to which I have modified and added to in many places.
I must agree with Bob’s conclusion:
Free Grace theology is still being worked out. It has really taken shape in the last 25 years. The Gospel Under Siege by Zane Hodges came out in 1981 and it was a seminal work on Free Grace theology. Prior to that Free Grace theology was rather loosely defined. Even today, as we shall see, there is still work to be done to nail down all of the particulars.
I must say at the outset that the Free Grace movement is a rather large tent and that not everyone will agree with what I am about to suggest are the essentials of Free Grace theology. However, I am convinced that these things are the essentials, and I am joined by key writers like Zane Hodges, Charles Ryrie, and Jody Dillow on these points.
Eight Essentials of Free Grace Theology
Though no one has formally set out to define what are the “essential elements” (i.e., sine qua nons) of the Basics of Free Grace Theology, and even less publish anything of the sort, there are no doubt eight core issues that define the Basics of Free Grace theology.
What are the essential truths that one must believe to be Free Grace?
The Grace Evangelical Society (GES) organization has primarily four main points of affirmation that they considered to be the essentials of Free Grace Theology:
Salvation
The sole condition for receiving eternal salvation from hell is faith (trust) in the Lord Jesus Christ, Who died a substitutionary death on the cross for man’s sin and rose from the dead (John 3:16-18; John 6:47; Acts 16:31).
No act of obedience, preceding or following faith in the Lord Jesus Christ, such as commitment to obey, sorrow for sin, turning from one’s sin, baptism or submission to the Lordship of Christ, may be added to, or considered as a part of, faith as a condition for receiving eternal salvation (Romans 4:5; Galatians 2:16; Titus 3:5). This saving transaction between God and the sinner is simply the giving and receiving of a free gift (Ephesians 2:8, 9; John 4:10; Revelation 22:17).
Assurance
The assurance of eternal salvation is based only on the promise God makes in His Word that everyone who trusts in Jesus Christ alone possesses eternal life (John 5:24; 1 John 5:9-13). Good works, which can and should follow regeneration, are not necessary for a person to have assurance of eternal life even though they may have a secondary, confirmatory value (Ephesians 2:10; Titus 3:8).
Discipleship (Growing in Christ)
The ultimate goal of the Holy Spirit’s work in the believer’s life is to produce spiritual maturity reflected in consistent Christlike behavior and attitudes (Galatians 5:22-25; Luke 14:25-33; Colossians 1:23-29). Therefore, obedience to the Word of God, while not necessary for obtaining eternal salvation from hell, is the essential responsibility of each Christian (Romans 6:12-23; Hebrews 5:13,14; 1 Corinthians 2:14–3:4). However, the Bible does not teach that this obedience will be manifested in all believers. If a believer does not yield to the ministry of the Holy Spirit in his experience, failure will result, evidenced by sinful acts or even prolonged disobedience (1 Corinthians 10:1-13; Galatians 5:16-21).
Motivation
The believer is assured of salvation from hell and is eternally secure, since that salvation is based solely upon the finished work of Jesus Christ (John 10:28,29; Romans 8:38, 39). Therefore, it is inconsistent with the Gospel and with Scripture to seek to gain or keep eternal salvation by godly living. The Scripture, however, does present several motivations for obedience in the Christian life.
1. A powerful motivation for living the Christian life is gratitude to God for saving us by His grace (Romans 12:1, 2; 2 Corinthians 5:14, 15; Galatians 2:20).
2. Believers should also be motivated by the knowledge that their heavenly Father both blesses obedience and disciplines disobedience in His children (Hebrews 12:3-11; Leviticus 26:1-45).
3. Finally, every Christian must stand before the Judgment Seat of Christ, not to determine his destiny in heaven or hell, but to assess the quality of his Christian life on earth (2 Corinthians 5:10; Revelation 22:12). Anticipating either reward or loss of reward at the Judgment Seat should also motivate believers to perseverance and to faithfulness to God’s revealed will (1 Corinthians 3:10-17, 9:24-27; James 5:8, 9; 1 John 2:28).
Each of those four points contain more than a single idea. In agreement with Bob, who noted the first 7 points, I added and 8th point, as a necessary corollary to understanding and defining the Basics of Free Grace Theology:
1. The only condition of eternal life is simple faith in Jesus
Not faith plus anything that follows. That is the Arminian position. Not faith that works. That is what many Reformed or 5-Points Calvinist advocate.
Here is what Arminianism and Calvinism teach in relations to this point. Both believe that perseverance in good works is required to make it to heaven. Here are the differences: Arminians say if a believer fails to persevere in good works, then he loses eternal life and he goes to hell. Many (but not all) Calvinists say if a believer fails to persevere in good works, then he proves he wasn’t a “true believer” in the first place and he goes to hell. There are no real differences in these views. Calvinists say you can’t lose eternal life. But they essentially believe you can lose it since no believer can be sure he will make it into the kingdom until he has died. Failure to persevere proves one didn’t have “true faith.” More on the nature of faith and on perseverance in a moment.
The Free Grace position has as its first characteristic that simply by believing in Jesus a person has eternal life. There are no strings attached whatsoever and no necessary works that follow either to confirm or validate one’s eternal status at the very moment faith in Jesus for eternal life occurs.
But what then is faith in Jesus?
2. Simple faith in Christ is intellectual assent
Stripped of its pejorative connotation, intellectual assent, or agreement, is a good definition of what faith is.Do you believe that Abraham Lincoln help change the slave policy in the United States? There is nothing you do as a result of believing this. You either believe or you do not. Do you believe people are going to stop at a red light? If so, you know what faith is from a Free Grace perspective.
There is no commitment, no decision of the will, no turning from sins, and no works that are part of faith in Christ in the promise of eternal life. It is passive. It is simply taking Him at His Word. The Free Grace view of simple faith in Jesus is just what it states. To be convinced or persuaded about a saving proposition concerning Jesus Christ (e.g., John 6:47) is what it means to believe in Him for eternal life. But what specifically must we believe about Jesus to have eternal life?
. The specific object of saving faith is Jesus and the result is the promise of eternal life to all who simply believe in Him
Compare 3 passages in John: 3:16; 6:47; 11:26.
These passages have three points in the saving proposition: 1) Condition: Faith, 2) Object of Faith: in Jesus, 3) Result: means a person has everlasting life. Without having this last point, the context is left open to the question: “What are you believing in Christ for?” Thus, I like to call these three necessary components the COR or bare minimum of what composes the saving message.
While Free Grace people believe in and proclaim the cross and the resurrection, all who simply just believe He died and rose again are wrong in thinking this guarantees eternal life.
Why? Does anyone know how a person could believe Jesus died and rose again and yet not believe in Jesus for eternal life in the biblical sense?
It is because a person must believe in justification by faith alone in order to have eternal life. It is not enough to believe that faith in Jesus is one of many conditions. One must believe that faith in Jesus is the only condition to receive eternal life. No strings attached. While believing in the basis that accomplished our salvation, life, death and resurrection, may supply the theological answer to how God can justify a guilty sinner, and may help one understand in order to influence one to believe in Christ (as Romans 3:21–4:25 shows), the only condition put forth to have eternal life is faith alone in Jesus (as John’s Gospel clearly shows since the disciples had eternal life as early as chapter 1 yet denied the resurrection).
The Arminian thinks that if he believes in Jesus and does good works he has eternal life, and believes he met the biblical requirement to attain that life. Yet, he has not really believed in the only saving proposition stated in the Bible: that all who simply believe in Jesus have everlasting life that can never be lost (see John 1:12; 2:23; 3:16; 5:24; 6:40, 47; 11:25-27; 20:31; Rom 3:21–4:25; Eph 2:8-9; Titus 3:5; Rev 22:17)
The same could be said of many Calvinist. This leads to a key question. If eternal life is freely given to all who simply believe in Jesus for eternal life, then what is the role of repentance in gaining eternal life? This leads to the fourth Free Grace distinctive.
4. Turning from sins is not faith and thus isn’t a condition of eternal life
Free Grace advocates must admit that turning from sins is not faith and is not a condition of eternal life. Please note: turning from sins is part of a Christian requirement not a requirement to become a Christian. Repentance is not a condition of eternal life according to Basic Free Grace Theology.
However, since many in the Free Grace camp believe that repentance is not turning from sins, but is changing one’s mind about Christ, there are many in the Free Grace camp that say that repentance is a synonym for faith in Christ.
Two interpretations exist in Free Grace about the relationship between repentance and eternal life:
The change of mind view. This was my view, as well as Bob and a number of Free Grace advocates for a long time. Bob, in fact, wrote his doctoral dissertation under Zane Hodges from 1983 to 1985 and defended this view.
According to this view in some contexts repentance is a condition of eternal life, but there repentance does not mean turning from sins, but a change of mind about Christ.
Let’s take a key example. Luke 13:3, 5: “Unless you repent, you will all likewise perish.” According to this way of thinking Jesus was saying, “Unless you change your minds about Me, that is, unless you believe in Me, you will all likewise be eternally condemned.”
However, this passage, like many others of the like, does not refer to eternal condemnation by using the word perish but to temporal death that will come upon the specific group and ultimately the nation if Christ’s words are not heeded.
Thus Luke 13:3, 5 really means, “Unless you repent, you will all likewise perish.” According to this view Jesus was saying, “Unless you turn from your sinning and come into fellowship with God, you will all likewise experience premature physical death.”
This view makes more sense and fits other passages.
For example see Luke 13:1-5. The issue there is physical death, not eternal condemnation. The warning was concerning national judgment unless the nation repented. Of course, if the nation had repented at the preaching of Jesus, it also would have believed in Him as the Messiah. But the warning Jesus gave concerned the destruction of the nation and of the temple. Because the nation didn’t repent, the Jewish Wars occurred about 35 years after this. And in A. D. 70 Jerusalem and the temple were destroyed and multitudes of Jews were killed.
The turning from sin view. Both Free Grace understandings of repentance say that turning from sins may put an unbeliever in a position to hear the gospel and believe it and be born again. Cornelius in Acts 10 and Lydia in Acts 16 are examples of this. But that is not to say that turning from sins is a condition of eternal life. It is simply to acknowledge that it is a good thing for unbelievers to turn from their sins and when they do so they are more likely to go to church and hear the saving message and be born again.
Time and space does not permit going over all repentance passages in this paper.
5. Perseverance in faith and good works is not a condition of eternal life
Many people believe only those who persevere in faith and good works will receive eternal life. Basic Free Grace Theology denies this.
Free Grace advocates believe that failure, even major failure, is possible in the Christian life.
First Corinthians 3:3 shows that by looking at the works of some believers, one cannot distinguish them from unbelievers.
First Corinthians 5:1-5 shows how the works of some believers are actually worse than the works of some unbelievers (see 1 Cor 5:10-11 and 6:8-11).
First Corinthians 11:30 and James 5:19-20 and 2 Tim 2:11-13 show that many believers do not persevere and die physically prematurely. Perseverance is not guaranteed and it is not a condition of eternal life.
6. Good works are not indispensable for assurance
Most Evangelicals believe that good works are indispensable for assurance. Hence a baby Christian cannot be sure of his salvation if he dies immediately since he has not produced any good works yet. Some have even suggested that a person cannot produce enough good works in less than 2 or 3 years, and even then they cannot be sure, just more hopeful.
Because they believe that good works are indispensable, most Evangelicals do not think that certainty of one’s eternal destiny is possible prior to death. Some even say it is presumptuous to even think of assurance in such a way.
If persevering is a requirement for getting eternal life, and if one cannot be sure until death that he will persevere, then we can never be sure of our eternal destiny as long as we remain alive. That is a horrible and defeating feeling.
Free Grace advocates reject this view.
We believe that the only condition of assurance is by believing the good news that Jesus guarantees eternal life to all who simply believe in Him.
In John 11:26 Jesus asked Martha, “Do you believe this?” She said “Yes, Lord.” She didn’t look to her works. She didn’t wonder about her future works or whether she would persevere in the future or not. She knew that didn’t impact her belief or her eternal life.
Let’s say I asked you, “Are you sure you are an American citizen?”
Would you even think about your works when trying to answer that question? No. Why not?
Similarly, we know we are citizens of heaven because we have a heavenly birth certificate and it is called John 3:16.
Another theological expression necessary to understand which I believe to be the very sine qua non of the Basics of Free Grace Theology is the following: “Assurance is of the essence of saving faith.”
This forms part of this 6th essential point. Not all Free Grace people agree with this, which I think is problematic. In fact, Bob noting the importance of this point said: “I think this point is implicit in the GES Affirmations, but it is not explicitly stated. If we rewrite it, I will push for it to be included.”
Let me say it this way: whenever a person believes in Jesus, he knows for sure he has everlasting life that can never be lost, because it does not depend on the recipient to earn it or keep it but solely on Jesus who freely offers it to those who simply just believe in Him for it.
Or, saying it the another way, if a person has never been sure that he has eternal life—that cannot be lost—simply by faith in Jesus, he has not yet been born again because he either does not understand the gospel offer, or has not yet believed in the biblical gospel.
I believe that until a person believes in this manner (whether or not he can articulate it) he is not born again (see my article titled “Certainty and Mental Assent Clarified in Romans 4:21-22” in scriptureunlocked.com).
Furthermore, the issue is also not about whether the phrase “eternal life” appears in one’s presentation. That is not the point. For even if one uses the phrase eternal life in one’s gospel presentation but the recipient does not understand what it means it is ultimately defeating since saying and hearing the phrase eternal life is not a formula or a magical incantation that cures all who hear it. The meaning of what eternal life conveys is what the person needs to know and believe. That is, the eternal life that Jesus offers does not mean life that is eternal unless I forfeit it by doing a heinous sin later. That is not what eternal life means or what the gospel that Jesus and the apostles preached. Unequivocally, a recipient having believed the former concept at the initial moment of the presentation, not only is not believing what the biblical concept means, but he subscribes a works salvation since at the inception of the offer he understands that by doing something at the back end he will get to keep the gift Jesus initially and only partly gave him at the front end. One can equally use synonymous terms like “salvation” (as in John 3:16-17) or “justification” (as in Romans 1:17; 3:21:24; 4:2-5) if the recipient upon hearing them understands that the transaction taking place, upon believing in Jesus for salvation or justification, conveys a once-and-for-all event that guarantees one’s eternal future because Jesus paid for our debt and by simply believing/trusting in His promise we have it. Period!
7. Eternal Life is not based on present or future judgment of works
A vital element of Free Grace theology is the doctrine of accountability as distinct from the doctrine of salvation. God judges everyone, believer and unbeliever, according to their works in this life. And after this life is over He will judge everyone according to their works.
Believers and unbelievers in this life have more or less joy in life depending on how they live. A person with eternal life who is walking in rebellion against God will be miserable (Luke 15, prodigal son). A person without eternal life who is seeking God may be reasonably happy (Acts 10, Cornelius).
8. Eternal Life and eternal rewards must be distinguished by noting that the former is a gift and the latter is earned
As a corollary to point 7 follows point 8. While everyone who believes in Christ receives eternal life as a free gift, rewards in the future are based on faith and works. While believers are responsible for their rewards, even rewards are based on God’s grace; for God even provides the means and aid in attaining these rewards, and in the end He does not owe anyone anything but gives it out of mercy (see Matt 20:1-16; 25:14-30; Luke 19:12-27; Rom 11:35).
Believers will be judged according to their works before the Millennium at the Judgment Seat of Christ (1 Cor 3:15; 2 Cor 5:10-11) to determine degrees of rewards in the life to come. Ruling with Christ and having authority over the nations will depend on our faithfulness to Him now (Rom 8:17-18; 2 Tim 2:11-13; Rev 2:26)? Thus believers should ask themselves: “Will we have the right to eat the 12 fruits of the tree of life? Will we get special clothes that mark us out as having been overcomers in this life (Rev 3:18; 19:8)? How abundant will our life be in the life to come?”
Unbelievers will be judged according to their works after the Millennium to determine their degree of suffering in the lake of fire (Rev 20:10-15).
Please note: The reason why people will be judged according to their works is not so that God can determine who gets into the kingdom. Kingdom entrance is determined based on our having believed in Jesus in this life not by works. Once having died without believing in Christ there are no more chances of being saved (see Heb 9:27-28).
According to the Free Grace perspective there is no “final judgment” of everyone, for the moment one dies without believing in Jesus is condemned already (John 3:18; 8:24). Christians will never be judged to determine their eternal destiny. That was settled at the moment they placed their faith in Christ for eternal life, and for the unbeliever that was settled the moment they died without believing in Christ.
Furthermore even the judgment of unbelievers at the Great White Throne Judgment is not strictly to determine their eternal destiny as implied in the previous paragraph. It is more to “announce” their eternal destiny and to announce their degree of punishment based on their deeds.
The doctrine of present and eternal rewards, as distinct from kingdom entrance or receiving eternal life by faith alone in Christ, is a key essential distinction of the Free Grace position.
Conclusion: Basics of Free Grace Theology
Gets its Name From the Fact that Eternal Life Is Truly a Free Gift Received by Anyone Who Simply
Believe in Jesus for it
Several pithy sayings express the Basics of Free Grace Theology:
· Faith alone in Christ alone.
· Assurance is of the essence of saving faith
· Eternal life is absolutely free.
· Eternal life is eternal.
· Faith is simple assent.
· All who simply believe in Jesus have everlasting life.
· There really are no strings attached.
· Our works play no role in justification or assurance.
· Accountability doesn’t contradict Free Grace.
· Major failure is possible in the Christian life.
· No matter what a believer does, he is eternally secure.
· Turning from sins is not a condition of eternal life.
· I’m sure I’m eternally secure because I believe in Jesus and all who believe in Him have everlasting life.
· Perseverance is a rewards issue, not an eternal life issue.
There is power in the Free Grace message because the Free Grace message draws out key principles from God’s Word.
Free Grace people know they have eternal life. That’s powerful. Gratitude is powerful. Love is powerful.
Free Grace people know Jesus is coming again and we will be judged by Him to determine our degree of eternal reward. That is powerful. Christ’ approval is something that can and should propel us through each day.
Finally, Free Grace people truly have good news that they can share with friends and love ones and strangers alike.
Most people witness like this: “I don’t know where I’m going when I die. If you have 5 minutes I can help you not know where you are going when you die.”
Is it any wonder that most people find it hard to witness. That is not good news, is it?
We have the real good news. We can say, “I know I have eternal life right now and that I will always have it no matter what. I know that I will spend eternity in God’s kingdom. If you have a few minutes I can show you how you can be sure you have eternal life now and forever. Simple, believe Jesus’ words in John 6:47, “Most assuredly, I say to you, he who believes in Me has everlasting life.”
Suscribirse a:
Enviar comentarios (Atom)
4 comentarios:
Hi Ricky:
I would strongly caution you on what Rene Lopez is teaching.
He is a member of the Grace Evangeical Society. These are the men (Zane Hodges & Bob Wilkin) who have created what is known as the Crossless gospel.
You can read about this false, reductionist interpretation of the Gospel at my blog.
http://indefenseofthegospel.blogspot.com/search/label/Zane%20Hodges
And at my blog you can click on the link Grace Family Journal and read The Tragedy of the Crossless Gospel
http://www.duluthbible.org/246451.ihtml
LM
Thank you Lou. As we have talked before, I hold to the Biblical position of FG and not the one of the GES. I hope that at some time I may be able to translate some of your work into Spanish. It is really needed in Puerto Rico and Latin America.
Ricky:
Are you any closer to being able to translate any of my articles into Spanish? I can suggest some that would be relatively easy to translate and make a strong impact.
Please advise.
Lou
Contact me via e-mail at
indefense06@mac.com
Publicar un comentario